SAFETY BULLETIN – Metal Fragment Embedded in Employee’s Eye
Recordable Injury / Serious Potential
Incident Description
Earlier in the shift, an employee performed overhead drilling of ten 3/8-inch anchors in a crawl space while wearing the required face shield. After completing the drilling, he transitioned to installing racks and running 2-inch EMT conduit, using a bandsaw to cut all-thread, Unistrut, and EMT. A face shield was not worn during these metal cutting and fabrication tasks. At approximately 1:00 p.m., the employee reported irritation in his left eye, which he believed was caused by Monokote after bumping his head on an I-beam. The following morning, a medical evaluation identified a small metal fragment embedded in his left iris that required removal by a specialist.
Root Cause Analysis – 5 Whys
- Changing Work Activities: The employee transitioned from overhead drilling to rack installation and conduit fabrication without reassessing task-specific hazards.
- PPE Selection: The potential for flying metal fragments during bandsaw cutting and fabrication was not recognized, and a face shield was not used.
- Task-Based Hazard Recognition: Face protection was tied to the overhead drilling activity rather than to the hazards of each task performed.
- Injury Recognition and Response: When the employee reported eye irritation, the possibility of an embedded foreign object was not recognized, and medical evaluation was delayed until the next morning.
- Foreign Material Exposure: The irritation was attributed to Monokote, delaying recognition of the actual injury mechanism.
Key Takeaways and Preventative Actions
Eye and face protection requirements are determined by the hazards of the task being performed, not the location or position of the work. Wearing the right PPE for one task does not mean it will be worn, or adequate, for the next—when the work changes, stop and evaluate the new risks.
Employees and field leadership must:
- Wear Appropriate Eye and Face Protection: Safety-rated glasses (ANSI Z87.1) must be worn at all times. Half face shields do not provide adequate eye protection on their own, so safety-rated glasses must always be worn underneath. Add a face shield over safety-rated glasses for any cutting, grinding, or drilling at shoulder height or above, and for any activity that produces flying debris that could reach the eyes.
- Reassess When Work Changes: Update the pre-task plan whenever activities or conditions change, and do not assume the previous task’s PPE is adequate.
- Verify PPE Before Work Begins: Foremen and Superintendents must confirm the correct eye, and face protection is available and being worn for each task.
- Report Eye Injuries Immediately: Report any suspected foreign object in the eye right away. Do not rub the eye or attempt to remove an embedded object.
- Do Not Assume the Cause: Never attribute eye irritation to dust, insulation, or Monokote without evaluating the possibility of an injury.
Why This Is Important to You
Your eyesight cannot be replaced. A small metal fragment traveling at high speed can penetrate the eye and cause permanent vision damage, even when it first feels like minor irritation. Here, the employee had worn a face shield earlier in the shift, but when the work changed, the PPE did not. Before cutting, grinding, drilling, or fabricating, ask yourself: What can become airborne, and are my eyes and face protected? Taking a few seconds to put on the right protection and speaking up the moment something gets in your eye, is always better than risking your vision.
STOP. THINK. REASSESS.
Before proceeding, ask:
- Has the task changed since I selected my PPE?
- Will this task create flying chips, fragments, sparks, or debris?
- Am I wearing safety glasses and a face shield where required?
- Have I reported any eye irritation or possible foreign object?
If the task creates flying debris, exercise your STOP WORK OBLIGATION until the right protection is in place. No task is so urgent that it cannot be stopped and reassessed.
Our expectation: Identify the hazards of every task, wear the right eye and face protection every time, reassess when work changes, and report eye injuries immediately.